I think that this is important, because to be honest, the language did seem a bit strange to me in a contemporary setting. However, I think that if I watched it again, I would may have a different outlook, especially with Denisof's words in mind.
*Swedish expression used when tickling someone, roughly "tickle, tickle, tickle" |
Or you could look at it the other way; that they were maybe afraid of taking something wrong, so they chose not to interpret and translate into our vernacular. Instead, they left it up to the audience to do so.
However, I don't think that this is a very compelling interpretation. For one thing, what Denisof said in the video seems to indicate a different interpretation. Second, and what I think is most important, there needs to be interpretation in order to produce an adaptation of any of Shakepeare's plays, including this one. There is not much in the way of stage direction; the plays are almost completely dialogue. That means that what is seen on screen, in this case, as an adaptation of Much Ado About Nothing is interpretation.
Overall, I really liked this adaptation. The only thing that bothered me at all was the language, and although I think it could still be a barrier, I like was Denisof had to say. Whedon left it up to the audience, left it up to me to find the beauty in the language.
The language of Whedon's version is an interesting topic for me. I focused on the language in Emma for a former post and so it's something I've thought on a bit for this movie as well. I really like the quote you found that says the language is left alone so the audience can hear and interpret the beauty of the language for itself. I would make the claim that the more you are around the kind of language being spoken in the movie/play, the more you can understand it without thought (kind of like learning a foreign language). If you think of it that way, it's almost easier to focus on the language if you're not looking at the setting and this movie could be used to help some understand both the language AND the play better.
ReplyDelete